Dependency Management in Shopify Modular Systems

Managing dependencies in Shopify‘s modular systems is essential for building scalable and maintainable e-commerce platforms. As Shopify’s codebase grows, challenges like high coupling, circular dependencies, and interface complexity arise. Here’s a quick breakdown of the key practices and tools discussed:

• Modular Design Benefits: Increases developer productivity, simplifies testing, and enhances scalability.
• Key Principles:
  • Define clear module boundaries using tools like Packwerk.
  • Enforce one-way dependency flow to prevent circular dependencies.
  • Standardize module communication with APIs and protocols.
• Tools:
  • Packwerk: Identifies dependency violations.
  • Wedge: Tracks module interactions.
  • Yarn: Manages dependencies efficiently.
• Best Practices:
  • Separate business logic from presentation layers.
  • Use Rails Engines for encapsulating features.
  • Minimize JavaScript bundle sizes and optimize resource loading.

These strategies help Shopify maintain a modular, high-performing system while addressing common dependency issues. Dive into the article for actionable details and examples.

Packwerk at Shopify

Key Principles of Dependency Management

Managing dependencies effectively is crucial for maintaining organized and scalable code in Shopify’s modular systems. These principles provide a structured way to tackle the challenges of dependency management.

Module Boundaries

Defining clear module boundaries keeps code organized and easier to maintain. For Shopify, tools like Packwerk help enforce these boundaries by identifying dependency and privacy violations . Unlike languages such as Java or Elixir, which have built-in mechanisms for boundary enforcement, Ruby on Rails requires additional tools to achieve proper module isolation. With strict boundaries in place, effective communication between modules becomes a priority.

Module Communication Standards

Consistent communication patterns between modules help avoid dependency issues and unintended side effects. Shopify achieves this by focusing on:

• Creating dedicated public APIs for clear interaction points.
• Restricting and standardizing how modules integrate with one another.
• Enforcing communication protocols at the interface level.

These practices ensure smoother interactions and set the stage for maintaining a one-way dependency flow.

One-Way Dependency Flow

A one-way dependency flow keeps the module structure clean and manageable. Shopify’s "Componentization" project highlighted this approach by reorganizing the codebase around real-world concepts instead of abstract software constructs . Tools like Wedge were developed to monitor interactions between components and enforce isolation during continuous integration.

To achieve one-way dependency flow:

• Modules should only load the components they explicitly depend on.
• The dependency graph must remain acyclic to avoid circular dependencies .
• Each module should maintain strong internal focus while staying loosely connected to others.

These principles form the foundation of Shopify’s approach to scalable, modular development.

Setting Up Dependencies in Shopify Modules

When developing Shopify modules, aim to structure them for clarity and minimal interdependence.

Building Reusable Components

Create components that are independent and stateless. These should rely solely on props for data, which makes them easier to reuse and reduces potential conflicts.

For example, Plug in SEO developed a frontend component library using React and Rails. By enforcing strict props-based data flow, managing versions with npm/Yarn, and applying semantic versioning, they streamlined their development process .

Shopify’s discount-app-components library is another example. It offers pre-built discount components that developers can integrate via npm or Yarn. This approach minimizes the need for custom code while staying aligned with Shopify’s design standards .

Separating Business Logic Dependencies

Keep business logic separate from presentation layers to ensure cleaner dependencies and better maintainability.

Here are some strategies to achieve this:

• Layer Communication: Let the business logic handle core functionality, while the presentation layer focuses on displaying updates.
• Event Management: Use the business layer to define progress events at key points. The UI layer can subscribe to these events without creating tight dependencies.
• Metadata Sharing: Share key metadata through a central module rather than duplicating it across layers.

Using Shopify and Rails Engines

Rails Engines are a great way to manage dependencies by encapsulating features into self-contained units. For instance, the DiscoApp Rails Engine extends ShopifyApp functionality while maintaining clear boundaries .

To successfully implement Rails Engines:

• Group features into separate engines to keep them modular.
• Use tools like Packwerk to enforce boundaries .
• Configure engines to handle their own routes, automating route management.

This method ensures dependencies remain clean, while also allowing for future updates and extensions.

Dependency Management Tools and Methods

Tools for Tracking Dependencies

Shopify developers rely on specific tools to tackle dependency challenges effectively. Shopify CLI is used to build and manage apps, themes, and Hydrogen storefronts, streamlining development workflows . Yarn oversees dependency management with features like parallel operations, caching, and checksum verification to ensure reliability . Meanwhile, Mechanic automates serverless tasks such as API connections, webhooks, file generation, and email workflows, making complex processes easier to handle .

Resolving Circular Dependencies

The Shopify Pricing team solved a circular dependency issue between their PricingEngine gem and its consumers by introducing the Repository pattern and a PricingRepositoryInterface .

If you encounter circular dependencies, here’s a practical approach:

• Use Packwerk to identify dependency violations .
• Run madge to create visual dependency graphs for TypeScript modules, making relationships clear .
• Apply the Repository pattern and use Dependency Injection where it fits .

These steps provide a clear path to untangle dependencies and maintain clean architecture.

Establishing Module API Standards

After handling dependency tracking and circular issues, setting clear module API standards is crucial. The Shopify App Bridge framework simplifies integration with the Shopify admin interface, ensuring smooth communication between apps and the platform .

To maintain high standards, focus on these key practices:

• Prioritize mobile-first designs to enhance usability.
• Use Shopify APIs to integrate real-time data effectively .
• Implement webhook subscriptions to handle events seamlessly .
• Follow accessibility guidelines to ensure inclusivity.

Additionally, Polaris can be used to align with Shopify’s native interface, ensuring consistency and modular integrity across the platform . These practices help create reliable and user-friendly modules.

Growing Modular Shopify Systems

Updating Dependencies

Shopify’s intricate codebase highlights the importance of managing dependency updates carefully.

When working with modular systems, here are a few key practices to follow:

• Back up your custom code: Always create backups of customized theme files. Custom changes, except for files in the Templates folder and settings_data.json in the Config folder, aren’t automatically included in theme updates .
• Review and test updates thoroughly: Check for changes that may affect CSS selectors and custom integrations, especially for Online Store 2.0 themes that receive automated updates .

Module Performance Tips

Optimizing performance in modular Shopify systems starts with a well-thought-out architecture. Shopify’s shift from a monolithic structure to a modular monolith offers valuable lessons for maintaining speed and efficiency .

Here are some effective performance strategies:

• Enforce strict boundaries between domains using tools like Wedge to monitor isolation progress .
• Use horizontal scaling for infrastructure components, aligning with Shopify’s simplicity-first philosophy .
• Conduct multi-layered testing, including unit, integration, and canary testing, to ensure system stability during scaling .

"almost all the cases where I’ve heard of a system that was built as a microservice system from scratch, it has ended in serious trouble… you shouldn’t start a new project with microservices, even if you’re sure your application will be big enough to make it worthwhile" – Martin Fowler

These strategies help maintain system efficiency while scaling and refining module connections.

Module Connection Optimization

After addressing performance, it’s crucial to fine-tune how modules interact. Reducing unnecessary dependencies and improving communication between components should be a priority.

Techniques for optimizing connections include:

• Minimizing JavaScript bundle size (e.g., keeping it below 16 KB) to improve load times
• Relying on native browser features instead of external frameworks when possible
• Using deferred loading for resources that aren’t immediately needed
• Wrapping JavaScript values in function scopes to avoid namespace conflicts

For better maintainability, Shopify advises organizing code around practical concepts like orders and shipping, rather than traditional software structures like models, views, and controllers . This approach simplifies dependency management and improves clarity.

Tools like Wedge can also assist in tracking and resolving boundary violations, ensuring proper isolation between components . This proactive approach minimizes dependency issues and keeps the system running smoothly.

Summary and Resources

Main Points Review

Let’s recap the essentials of effective dependency management. The goal is to balance performance and maintainability by managing bundle size, simplifying module connections, and ensuring thorough testing.

Key priorities for a strong strategy include:

• Bundle Size Control: Aim to keep JavaScript bundles under 16 KB for better performance .
• Use Native Browser Features: Favor built-in browser capabilities instead of relying on external frameworks .
• Strategic Resource Loading: Optimize loading by using defer and async attributes .

To support these efforts, performance tools play a crucial role:

These tools and strategies align closely with the modular design principles discussed earlier.

E-commerce Dev Group Services

Implementing these strategies can be complex, but working with experienced partners can make it easier. E-commerce Dev Group specializes in Shopify dependency management, focusing on performance optimization and scalable architecture. Their expertise includes custom theme development, performance audits, module integration, and theme customization.

By leveraging Shopify’s CDN with Cloudflare, they ensure efficient asset delivery while maintaining strict dependency boundaries . Their services are designed to meet Shopify’s performance standards.

For more details, visit E-commerce Dev Group.

Related Blog Posts

• Composable Commerce with Shopify Modules
• Best Practices for Scalable Shopify Themes
• How Scalable Theme Architecture Improves Shopify Stores
• Theme Dependencies in Shopify: What to Know