How Discounts Affect Shopify Cart Recovery

Explore how targeted discounts can effectively recover abandoned carts and boost e-commerce sales without sacrificing profit margins.

Did you know? Nearly 7 out of 10 online shopping carts are abandoned, costing e-commerce businesses billions annually. Discounts are a proven way to recover lost sales. Here’s how they work:

  • Timing is critical: Send a discount email within 1 hour to achieve a 20.3% conversion rate.
  • Why shoppers abandon carts: Unexpected costs (47%), account requirements (25%), and slow delivery (24%).
  • Top discount types:
    • Percentage discounts: Boost conversions by 20-25%.
    • Fixed discounts: Great for smaller purchases.
    • Free shipping: Solves the #1 abandonment reason.

Quick tip: Combine discounts with personalized emails and A/B testing to maximize results while protecting profit margins.

Start using targeted discounts to turn abandoned carts into loyal customers.

What Causes Cart Abandonment and Why It Matters

What Is Cart Abandonment?

Cart abandonment happens when shoppers add items to their online cart but leave the site without completing their purchase. According to the Baymard Institute, the average cart abandonment rate is a staggering 69.99%. In other words, nearly 7 out of 10 potential sales slip through the cracks before reaching checkout.

Why does this happen? Common reasons include:

  • Unexpected costs like shipping or taxes (47%)
  • Account creation requirements (25%)
  • Security concerns (19%)
  • Complicated checkout processes (18%)
  • Slow delivery times (24%)

These obstacles make it harder for businesses to turn browsers into buyers.

The Revenue Impact of Cart Abandonment

Cart abandonment costs e-commerce businesses a fortune. Dynamic Yield‘s 2023 report estimates that abandoned carts result in $18 billion in lost sales revenue every year [2].

Abandonment rates also differ by industry. For example:

  • Beauty and personal care: 82.63%
  • Food and beverage: 44.95%

Mobile users are especially prone to abandoning carts, with a rate of 85.65%, compared to 69.75% on desktop. This highlights how crucial it is to optimize for mobile shoppers.

A frustrating checkout process is another major culprit. If a website is slow to load, 90% of shoppers will leave their carts behind. And more than half will abandon their purchase if the checkout takes over 30 seconds. These technical issues can severely hurt sales.

Common Discount Types for Recovering Abandoned Carts

Percentage Discounts

Percentage discounts, especially tiered ones, work well for larger purchases and are particularly attractive to shoppers under 35. A tiered approach can help boost conversions by offering increasing discounts based on cart value:

  • 5% off orders under $50
  • 15% off orders between $50–$100
  • 20% off orders over $100

Studies show that cart recovery campaigns using percentage discounts result in 20-25% higher conversion rates compared to those with no incentives. This tactic becomes even more effective during the holidays when customers are hunting for the best deals.

Fixed Amount Discounts

Fixed discounts resonate more with smaller purchases because they provide a clear and immediate benefit. For example, Casper successfully used a flat $75 off on their mattresses, which proved more enticing than a comparable percentage-based discount for such high-ticket items.

Fixed amount discounts are most effective when:

  • The discount is straightforward (e.g., $10 or $25 off)
  • The product price is on the lower to medium end
  • You want to emphasize immediate savings

Free Shipping Offers

Free shipping is a strong motivator, especially for customers aged 46 and older. Since unexpected shipping costs lead to 47% of cart abandonments, waiving shipping fees can significantly impact recovery rates. To maximize its appeal, you can:

  • Set a minimum order value for free shipping
  • Offer it as a limited-time promotion
  • Combine it with other discounts during busy shopping seasons

Data shows abandoned cart emails with free shipping offers achieve a 31.81% conversion rate, making it one of the most effective strategies on platforms like Shopify.

Use Shopify’s analytics to track performance and identify the best discount combinations for your audience and products. With these discount types in mind, you can focus on implementing them in ways that drive the greatest results.

How to Use Discounts Effectively on Shopify

Shopify

Timing Discounts for Maximum Impact

A well-timed email sequence can help recover up to 20% of abandoned carts [1]. Here’s a simple three-step approach:

  • Send a friendly reminder within the first hour.
  • Follow up 24 hours later with a coupon code.
  • Wrap it up 48 hours later by adding urgency – use an expiring coupon and a cart reminder.

During busy shopping seasons like Black Friday or the holidays, consider speeding up this timeline to catch impulse buyers.

Customizing Discounts for Individual Shoppers

Personalized discounts can make a big difference. Shopify’s discount tools let you create offers tailored to customer behavior and purchase history from the last 30 days [1]. This approach helps address specific customer concerns and improves cart recovery rates.

For example, MVMT Watches boosted conversions by 15% and cut cart abandonment by 20% by personalizing discounts based on customer segments and purchase history.

Testing Different Discount Approaches

To refine your discount strategy, A/B testing is essential. Instead of relying on guesswork, testing helps you discover what resonates most with your audience.

Here are some elements you can test:

Test Element Variables to Consider
Timing Immediate vs. Delayed Offers
Threshold Minimum Purchase Requirements

"Split testing pricing and discounts on your Shopify store can help you increase sales, attract more customers and boost conversion rates." [3]

Focus on testing one variable at a time and gather data over two weeks before making changes. Use Shopify’s analytics tools to track metrics like conversion rates and recovered revenue [3].

Keep in mind: while aggressive discounts might drive short-term results, they can cut into your margins. Balance your recovery goals with profitability by testing different discount levels and combinations. Tracking key metrics ensures your strategies remain effective and sustainable over time.

Shopify Abandoned Cart Discount: How to Add Discount Codes

How to Measure the Success of Discount Campaigns

Measuring the success of your discount campaigns is essential to ensure you’re not just recovering abandoned carts but also maintaining profitability and refining your approach.

Key Metrics and Analytics Tools

To track performance, focus on these key metrics using Shopify’s built-in analytics:

Metric Target Benchmark Purpose
Recovery Rate 10-20% Tracks the percentage of carts recovered
Email Open Rate >30% Measures how effective your recovery emails are
Click-Through Rate >10% Assesses engagement with recovery emails
Conversion Rate >3% Evaluates how many clicks turn into purchases

Shopify’s Sales by Discount Code Report offers detailed insights, including:

  • Transactions per discount code
  • Gross and net sales
  • Breakdown of new vs. returning customers
  • Returns and refunds
  • Overall campaign performance

"The report shows the results of the campaign and marketing activities contribute to attracting new customers or increasing repeat purchases." – Mipler Team

For deeper insights and real-time tracking, consider third-party tools. Keep in mind that Shopify’s discount reports may have a slight delay, so check regularly to stay updated.

Calculating ROI

To measure the return on investment (ROI) for your discount campaigns, use this formula:

ROI = (Increased Sales – Marketing Spend) / Marketing Spend × 100

While some channels may take time to show returns, tracking ROI ensures your campaigns are on the right track. Don’t forget to factor in customer lifetime value (CLV) – the total revenue a customer generates over time – when evaluating the long-term success of your efforts.

By monitoring these metrics through Shopify’s analytics dashboard and adjusting your strategy based on the data, you can pinpoint which discount types and amounts deliver the best results. Regular reviews will help you balance offering discounts and maintaining strong profit margins.

Up next, we’ll dive into how to ensure your discount strategies remain both effective and profitable.

Tips for Balancing Discounts and Profit Margins

Avoiding Excessive Discounting

Discounts can be a great tool for recovering abandoned carts, but overusing them can backfire. Too many discounts might hurt your brand’s image, shrink profit margins, and even train customers to wait for sales instead of buying right away. To avoid this, consider these tactics:

  • Limit how often you offer discounts.
  • Set minimum purchase amounts to qualify for discounts.
  • Focus on targeted offers that align with your goals.

A good example is Sephora‘s tiered discount system. They offer deals like 10% off for purchases over $50 or 15% off for purchases over $100. This approach encourages customers to spend more while keeping profit margins intact. To make this work for your business, monitor customer habits and adjust thresholds based on your average order value and margins.

Careful management of discounts, paired with other cart recovery strategies, can help you stay profitable.

Combining Discounts with Other Recovery Methods

Discounts work best when paired with other recovery techniques. Here’s how you can combine them effectively:

  1. Multi-Channel Approach
    Start with non-discount reminders, like emails or retargeting ads showcasing the abandoned products. Introduce discounts later in follow-ups to avoid creating an expectation for immediate deals.
  2. Strategic Segmentation
    Focus on high-value customers by offering tailored discounts. This personalized approach often delivers better results than blanket offers and helps maintain your margins.

To make the most of your efforts while keeping profits in check:

  • Set minimum purchase requirements to avoid losing money on small orders.
  • Use A/B testing to experiment with different discount levels and find what works best.
  • Add urgency to your campaigns with time-sensitive offers.

Conclusion: Using Discounts to Improve Cart Recovery

Recovering abandoned carts with discounts requires a smart strategy that boosts sales without eating into your profits. Timing is everything – sending cart recovery emails within an hour leads to a 20.3% conversion rate, but that number drops significantly after 24 hours.

Examples from businesses show how well-targeted discounts can make a big difference. The best results come from a mix of personalized offers, well-timed actions, and constant performance tracking. This approach tackles why customers abandon carts while keeping profits intact.

Three main factors drive success:

  • Personalized discounts that match specific customer needs
  • Quick follow-ups with recovery emails or offers
  • Ongoing tracking and adjustments to improve outcomes

For even better results, pair discount offers with other tactics like personalized emails or retargeting ads. Using multiple channels strengthens customer connections and helps recover lost sales without sacrificing profit margins.

Cart recovery isn’t just about closing the sale – it’s about building long-term customer loyalty. Focus on tailored offers, timely outreach, and consistent monitoring to make your discount strategy work without hurting your bottom line.

Related Blog Posts

Share Article:

Could you scale faster if you had a team of specialist on
standby to handle all of your Shopify tasks?

Design. Development. Support

A dedicated team on standby, for whatever you need